How to compare contractor bids
Short answer
Bids can only be compared when they price the same thing. Give every bidder one written scope, ask for materials by brand and model, and line the answers up side by side. A bid far below the others usually means work was left out, and California's license board says in as many words that accepting one may lead to a dispute.
The problem with three prices
Three contractors look at the same bathroom and send back $14,200, $19,800 and $22,500. Most people read that as one cheap contractor and two expensive ones. Far more often it is three different bathrooms: one bid assumes the subfloor is sound, one includes moving the drain, one has a tile allowance that will not buy the tile you pointed at.
The California Contractors State License Board states the fix in one sentence. Get at least three written bids, "and make sure you're comparing bids based on identical plans, specifications, and scope of work".
Write the scope yourself
It does not need to be professional. One page is enough:
- what is being removed and who hauls it away
- what is being built or installed, room by room
- materials you have already chosen, by brand and model
- anything you are supplying yourself
- who gets the permit
- the condition you expect the site left in each day and at the end
Hand the same page to every bidder. When one of them tells you something on it is a bad idea, listen, then update the page and send the new version to all of them.
Ask for the bid in pieces
A single total hides everything. Ask each bidder to break the price out, at least into demolition, each trade, materials, permit fees and their own overhead and profit. Not every contractor will go as deep as you like, and a refusal to break down anything at all is information.
The specificity standard to hold them to comes from the CSLB's contract guidance: the document should read "install oak kitchen cabinets, manufactured by Company XYZ, model 01381A, as per the plan", not just "install kitchen cabinets". A bid that says "install vanity" has not priced a vanity. It has priced the cheapest vanity that fits.
Allowances are where bids quietly differ
An allowance is a placeholder amount for something not yet chosen: $2,000 for light fixtures, $6 a square foot for tile. Two bids with the same total can hide very different allowances, and the contractor with the low allowance looks cheaper until you go shopping.
| What to line up | Why it moves the price |
|---|---|
| Allowance amounts for each unselected item | A low allowance becomes an extra later |
| Named brand and model for selected items | "Or equivalent" lets the cheaper product in |
| Permit fees included or excluded | The Arizona Registrar says estimates should state who obtains permits |
| Demolition and disposal | Often omitted from the lowest bid |
| Start date and duration | A contractor who can start tomorrow has no backlog |
| Payment schedule | Front-loaded schedules shift risk to you |
The low bid
Regulators are consistent on this, and blunt.
The CSLB: beware of any bid substantially lower than the others, because "it probably indicates that the contractor made a mistake or is not including all the work quoted by their competitors", and a low-bidding contractor may cut corners to make a profit.
The Texas Attorney General: beware of the "low-ball" bidder, who "may not plan to include all the specific tasks you might expect, may use very cheap, inexperienced labor, or second-rate materials".
The FTC: do not automatically pick the lowest bid, and ask about large differences.
That last piece is the practical one. Call the low bidder and go through your scope line by line. Either they find what they missed and revise, or they explain a real efficiency, or they get vague. All three outcomes are useful.
A low bid from an unlicensed operator carries a second cost. The CSLB warns that the risks of possible financial and legal consequences outweigh any benefits a lower bid may seem to offer.
The high bid
A high number is not automatically padding. Ask the same question in reverse: what is in your price that I might not see in the others? Sometimes the answer is a better waterproofing system, a permit the others ignored, or a realistic figure for the rot everyone suspects is behind the tub. Sometimes the contractor is busy and has priced the job at what it would take to make room for it. That is honest too.
Beyond the number
Price is one column. Add these before deciding:
- Verified license and insurance for each bidder. See how to check a contractor license.
- Who will be on site. The owner, a lead carpenter, or subcontractors you have not met.
- How changes are priced. A stated markup and a written change order process, covered in change orders.
- Reference calls, made by you, to jobs like yours.
Our bid comparison worksheet puts all of this on one printable page.
One contractor will not put the bid in writing. Should I keep them in the running?
No. Every regulator quoted here says written. A contractor who will not write down a price will not be easier to pin down after the work has started.
Is it fair to ask a bidder to match a lower price?
You can ask. Be aware of what you are asking for: the same job for less money comes out of labor quality, materials or margin, and you will not be told which.
Sources
- California CSLB: How do I find the right licensed contractor?
- California CSLB: What should I look for in a contract and binding agreements?
- Texas Attorney General: How to avoid home improvement scams
- FTC: How to avoid a home improvement scam
- Arizona Registrar of Contractors: Before you hire a contractor
Sources last checked: November 2026. Written by the Before You Hire a Pro editorial desk. Report an error.