What is a change order, and how should you handle one?
Short answer
A change order is a written amendment to your contract that states what is changing, what it costs and how it affects the schedule, signed by you and the contractor before the changed work is done. If a change is not in writing with a price, you have agreed to pay a number you have not seen yet.
The rule in one line
No signed change order, no changed work.
California's license board states it as a legal requirement for home improvement contracts: if the contract price or scope of work needs to be changed, it must be done with a written change order, signed by the customer and contractor prior to the change, which then becomes part of the contract. New Jersey's statute likewise requires all changes in the terms and conditions of a home improvement contract over $500 to be in writing.
Where your state has no such rule, put the same sentence in your contract.
Why changes happen
Three reasons, and they deserve different responses.
You changed your mind. A different tile, an added outlet, a window where the plan had wall. This is your cost, and the Texas Attorney General warns that most contractors will not allow you to change your mind for free; often a service charge applies for changing the work order, and that charge should be covered in the contract.
Something was hidden. Rot under the tub, knob-and-tube wiring in the wall, a drain that runs uphill. Nobody could price it exactly from outside. A good contract anticipates the likely ones with unit prices agreed in advance.
The bid left something out. The low bidder's missing line items return as "extras". This is the change order as business model, and it is the reason comparing bids line by line matters before you sign.
What a change order should say
- a number and date (Change Order 3)
- a description of the change, as specific as the original scope
- the price, as a fixed amount where possible, with labor and materials shown
- the effect on the completion date, even if it is "none"
- the new contract total
- when the extra is payable, slotted into the existing payment schedule
- both signatures
Each of you keeps a copy with the contract. California's guidance is to update the contract whenever you add or subtract work, substitute materials or equipment, or change the completion date.
Set the terms before you need them
Changes are negotiated at the worst possible moment: the wall is open, the crew is standing there, and the contractor is the only bidder. Take the pressure out in advance by writing these into the original contract.
- A markup rate for changes. A stated percentage over cost for overhead and profit on extra work.
- Unit prices for likely surprises. So much per sheet of subfloor replaced, per foot of rotted framing, per added outlet.
- A stop-and-call rule. Any discovery that will add cost stops that portion of work until you have a written price.
- A threshold for speed. Changes under a small figure may be approved by text message and written up within a day or two. Above it, paper first.
- Credits work the same way. Deleting work produces a written deductive change order with a price, not a vague promise to "take care of you at the end".
Keeping count
Keep a running list: original contract price, each change order, new total. Compare it with the payment schedule every time you write a check. People who track changes this way are rarely surprised by the final invoice. People who say "just do it, we'll sort it out" usually are.
Be careful with "while we're here". It is the most expensive phrase in remodeling. Ask for the price in writing first, every time, and decide the next morning.
When a contractor does extra work unasked
If your contract requires signed change orders and the contractor did extra work without one, you are in a stronger position than if the contract says nothing. Do not refuse to discuss it. If the work was necessary and fairly priced, paying for it keeps the job moving. But get it documented before the next payment, and restate the rule in writing.
Is a text message a valid change order?
It is evidence of an agreement. It will usually lack a price breakdown, a schedule effect and a signature. Use texts to approve small changes quickly, then get them onto a signed form.
The contractor wants payment in full for each change immediately. Is that normal?
It is negotiable. Tying payment for a change to completion of that change is consistent with the general principle that payments should not run ahead of the work.
Sources
- California CSLB: What is a contract?
- California CSLB: What should I look for in a contract and binding agreements?
- New Jersey home improvement contractor law, 56:8-151
- Texas Attorney General: How to avoid home improvement scams
Sources last checked: November 2026. Written by the Before You Hire a Pro editorial desk. Report an error.