Comparing three bids: worksheet
Print this, write a bidder's name at the top of each column, and fill it in from their written estimates. Gaps in a column are questions for that bidder. Do not look at the bottom line until the rows above it are complete.
Side by side
| Compare | Bidder A | Bidder B | Bidder C |
|---|---|---|---|
| Business name on the estimate | |||
| License or registration number, verified by me | |||
| License category covers this job | |||
| Liability insurance certificate received from agent | |||
| Workers' compensation in place | |||
| Estimate is written and itemized | |||
| Covers my full written scope (note anything missing) | |||
| Demolition and disposal included | |||
| Key materials named by brand and model | |||
| Allowances, in dollars | |||
| Permit: who pulls it, and is the fee included | |||
| Start date | |||
| Working days to finish | |||
| Who is on site daily | |||
| Subcontractors named | |||
| Deposit asked for | |||
| Payment schedule tied to milestones | |||
| Lien waivers offered with payments | |||
| Change order terms and markup | |||
| Workmanship warranty, length and terms | |||
| References called: what they said | |||
| Total price |
How to fill it in
- I gave every bidder the same written scope.
- I am working from written estimates, not from memory of a conversation.
- Where a row is blank for one bidder, I asked them and wrote down the answer.
- I adjusted for differences: if one allowance is $1,500 lower than the others, I added it back in my head before comparing totals.
- I asked the lowest bidder to walk through my scope line by line.
- I asked the highest bidder what their price includes that the others might not.
Reading the result
A bid is comparable when its rows match the others. Totals mean little until then.
California's license board says to compare bids based on identical plans, specifications and scope of work, and to beware of any bid substantially lower than the others, since it probably indicates a mistake or missing work. The Texas Attorney General notes that most legitimate bids fall into a fairly close range. So look for the outlier and find out why it is one.
Three patterns come up again and again:
- Low total, thin rows. Missing demolition, low allowances, vague materials. The price will grow.
- Middle total, full rows. Usually the honest picture of what the job costs.
- High total, full rows plus extras. Ask what the extras are. They may be worth having, or you may be paying for a busy contractor's reluctance.
Then weigh the rows that are not about money. A contractor whose license checks out, whose agent sent the insurance certificate the same day and whose references answered the phone has shown you how the job will be run.
Should the cheapest complete bid win?
If the rows match and the references are good, price is a fair tiebreaker. The FTC's advice is only that you should not choose the lowest bid automatically.
Sources
- California CSLB: How do I find the right licensed contractor?
- Texas Attorney General: How to avoid home improvement scams
- FTC: How to avoid a home improvement scam
Sources last checked: November 2026. Report an error.