How to check a contractor's references and past work
Short answer
Ask for three recent customers with jobs like yours, call them yourself, and ask specific questions about schedule, money and problems. Then go past the list the contractor chose: California's license board suggests suppliers, subcontractors and the local courthouse, where unpaid bills and lawsuits show up.
The list they give you is an advertisement
No contractor hands over the phone number of an unhappy customer. A reference list tells you the contractor has at least three people willing to take a call, which is worth knowing and not much more. The useful information comes from how you use the list and from people who are not on it.
The Texas Attorney General's advice sets the standard for the first part: ask to speak to satisfied customers, "and ask them if you can visit their homes to inspect the work".
Ask for the right references
- Recent. Finished in the last year or so, with the crew the contractor has now.
- Similar. A lovely deck says little about a bathroom with a tiled shower.
- One older job. Three to five years back, to hear how the work has aged and whether the contractor returned for anything.
- One in progress, if they will allow a visit. A site in mid-job shows you tidiness, protection of the house and who is actually there.
Questions that get real answers
"Were you happy?" gets "yes". Ask things that need a story.
- What was the original price, and what did you finally pay? What made up the difference?
- When was it supposed to finish, and when did it?
- Who was on site day to day? Did you see the owner?
- What went wrong, and what did they do about it?
- How were changes handled? In writing, with a price, before the work?
- Did you ever hear from a supplier or subcontractor about not being paid?
- Have you needed them back since? Did they come?
- Would you hire them again for the same kind of job?
Listen for hesitation on the last one. People are polite about contractors they would never rehire.
The people who are not on the list
California's Contractors State License Board gives the most useful advice here that we have read from any regulator. It suggests that local customers, material suppliers, subcontractors and financial institutions are good reference sources "to check whether the contractor is financially responsible". Its lien prevention page goes further: check your contractor's reputation for paying subcontractors and materials suppliers, "and check for lawsuits at the local courthouse".
That is three checks most homeowners never make.
Suppliers. Ask the contractor where they buy. Call the supplier's contractor desk and ask whether the account is in good standing. Some will not say; some will say a great deal. The Illinois Attorney General's guide makes the same suggestion: get the names of suppliers and ask if the contractor makes timely payments.
Subcontractors. If you know an electrician or plumber, ask whether they have worked for this general contractor and how payment went. A general contractor who pays subs late is one whose subs may lien your house. See mechanics liens.
Court records. Most county courts have an online case search. Search the business name and the owner's name. One dispute in ten years of trading is normal. A row of collection suits from suppliers is the financial picture the references could not give you.
Complaint records
Regulators and consumer agencies keep them, with caveats.
- The FTC suggests checking with the local home builders association and consumer protection officials to see whether complaints have been filed.
- State license lookups often show discipline. Massachusetts tells homeowners to check registration status and history, such as complaints, in its Contractor Hub. Washington's tool shows lawsuits against the bond and license violations.
- In Missouri, the Attorney General's advice is to contact the Attorney General's Office and the Better Business Bureau to learn about complaints.
No complaints does not mean no problems. Many unhappy customers never file, and a business that renamed itself last year starts clean. That is another reason to check how long the license or registration has been held.
Reading online reviews
The FTC's guidance is to read reviews critically and use rating sites you trust. In practice:
- read the three-star reviews first, since they tend to describe what actually happened
- look at how the contractor answers criticism
- be suspicious of a burst of five-star reviews in one week
- search the business name with "complaint" and "scam", as the FTC suggests
Looking at the work
If a past customer lets you visit, you do not need a builder's eye. Look at edges and endings: where tile meets a wall, where trim meets the floor, how paint lines run, whether doors close cleanly. Careful people are careful at the edges.
Ask to see the ordinary parts too. Anybody photographs the finished kitchen. The condition of the garage they stored materials in tells you how they will treat your house.
If a contractor cannot or will not provide references, the Illinois Attorney General counts that among its warning signs, alongside refusing proof of insurance.
How many references should I call?
Call at least two of the three, and try to reach one person who is not on the list at all. Fifteen minutes on the phone is cheap against the cost of the job.
The contractor is new and has few references. Should I rule them out?
Not necessarily. Ask where they worked before and call that employer. Keep the job smaller, the deposit lower and the payment schedule tighter until they have a record with you.
Sources
- California CSLB: How do I find the right licensed contractor?
- California CSLB: How to prevent a mechanics lien
- Texas Attorney General: How to avoid home improvement scams
- Illinois Attorney General: Home Repair and Construction, What You Should Know and Avoid home repair fraud
- FTC: How to avoid a home improvement scam
- Mass.gov: HIC homeowner resources
- Washington L&I: Hiring a contractor
- Missouri Attorney General: Scams to avoid after disasters
Sources last checked: November 2026. Written by the Before You Hire a Pro editorial desk. Report an error.