before you hire a pro

When it goes wrong

What should you do if a mechanics lien is filed on your house?

Short answer

Do not ignore it and do not pay it on the spot. Find out who filed it and for what, check whether they met the notice and filing deadlines your state requires, and demand payment proof from your contractor. Many liens are invalid because a deadline was missed. If the claimant will not release an invalid lien, a court can order it removed.

What has happened

Someone who supplied labor or materials for work on your property says they were not paid, and has recorded a claim against the property at the county recorder's office. That is a mechanics lien. California's license board describes it as a "hold" against your property which, if unpaid, allows a foreclosure action.

The claimant may be your contractor. Often it is someone you have never dealt with: a subcontractor or a lumber supplier your contractor did not pay. The uncomfortable rule, in the California board's words, is that the homeowner is ultimately responsible for payment even if they have already paid the direct contractor. Texas law works the same way, according to its Attorney General: if a subcontractor or supplier who furnished labor or materials is not paid, the property may be subject to a lien for the unpaid amount.

A lien on the title can stop you refinancing, borrowing against the house or selling it until it is dealt with.

First 48 hours

  1. Get a copy of the recorded lien from the county recorder if you only have a letter.
  2. Identify the claimant and the amount. What did they supply, and when?
  3. Tell your contractor in writing. Ask for proof that this party was paid, or for payment to be made now. Your contract is with the contractor; resolving their unpaid bills is their job.
  4. Stop further payments to the contractor until the lien is resolved, to the extent your contract allows. If you still hold money, that is your bargaining position. Consider a joint check to the contractor and the claimant.
  5. Pull your records: lien waivers, cancelled checks, any preliminary notices you received.
  6. Call a construction or real estate attorney if the amount is significant. Lien law is technical and the deadlines are short.

Is it valid? The California checklist

Lien rights are created by statute and lost by missing steps. California's board publishes the checklist for that state, and it shows the kind of things to look for anywhere.

Preliminary notice. A subcontractor or material supplier has 20 days after beginning work or delivering materials to serve you a Preliminary Notice. If the notice is late, the claim is only valid for work done or materials delivered from 20 days before the notice onward. Direct contractors and laborers do not have to give this notice.

Time to record. The claimant must record the lien within 90 days of completion of the work, of when you began using the improvement, or of when you accepted it. If you recorded a Notice of Completion, the period is shorter: 60 days for a direct contractor and 30 days for a subcontractor or supplier.

Notice with the lien. A Notice of Mechanics Lien must accompany the claim, with a proof of service affidavit.

Time to sue. The claimant must file a lien foreclosure action within 90 days of recording the lien. The board notes that a claimant with a valid claim will often fail to follow through, making the lien invalid.

Licensing. Anyone can record a lien, but in California an unlicensed contractor cannot foreclose on a mechanics lien if the work is valued at more than $500.

Substance. The board adds that a lien may not be valid if the work was not completed or the supplies were not included in the plans or contracts.

Other states have different periods and notices. Use this as a list of questions for your own state, not as its answers.

If the lien looks valid

A valid lien from an unpaid supplier is a debt attached to your house. The realistic options:

  • Your contractor pays it, and the claimant records a release. Press for this first, in writing, with a deadline.
  • You pay the claimant directly from money you still owe the contractor, in exchange for a recorded release and an unconditional lien waiver. Get your contractor's written agreement that the payment is credited against the contract.
  • You pay it on top of what you already paid, and pursue the contractor for the double payment through the licensing board, a recovery fund where one exists, or court.

The third outcome is the one lien waivers are designed to prevent. If you collected an unconditional waiver from this claimant covering the period in question, show it to them and to your attorney.

If the lien looks invalid

California's board sets out the steps there.

  1. Write to the claimant by certified, registered or express mail. Identify the defects you have found, ask for the lien to be removed, and remind them that if you have to hire an attorney to remove it, the court can award you reasonable attorney fees. Send it to the claimant's last known verified address, and keep a copy and the postage receipt.
  2. Wait for the response. The board notes that sometimes the letter is enough.
  3. Petition the court. If the claimant does not remove the lien and the time to take action on it has passed, you can petition the court to release the property from the lien.

An invalid lien does not disappear by itself. The board's warning is that a lien stays in the county records and on your title until you take action to remove it.

Your contractor's part

A lien from a subcontractor or supplier usually means your contractor took your money and did not pass it on. That is a contract breach and, for a licensed contractor, a matter for the board. File a complaint with the license board alongside whatever else you do. In Texas, where payments for a homestead improvement over $5,000 must go into a construction account, the Attorney General suggests monitoring deposits and disbursements to subcontractors, laborers and vendors; if you arranged access to those records, look at them now.

It may also be a sign of wider financial trouble. Expect other claimants. Ask the contractor for a complete list of unpaid subcontractors and suppliers on your job, and compare it with the notices you received.

Warning

Do not sign anything a claimant or contractor sends you "to clear this up" without reading it carefully. Some documents offered at this stage are new promises to pay.

Liens from your own contractor

If the claimant is the contractor you hired and you are withholding payment over defects, the lien is their side of the standoff. The answer is usually negotiation over a specific list, as described in final payment and the punch list, with the board complaint and court as the next steps.

Can they really foreclose on my house over a few thousand dollars?

A valid lien allows a foreclosure action if it goes unpaid, as California's board states. In practice claimants want payment, and most liens end in payment, settlement or expiry. Take it seriously without assuming the worst.

How do I know a lien has been removed?

Ask for a recorded release of lien and check the county recorder's index yourself. A letter saying "we consider this closed" is not a release.

Does a lien affect my credit?

It is a claim against the property recorded in county records. Its direct effect is on what you can do with the title. Ask your lender how it treats one if you are about to refinance.

Sources

Sources last checked: November 2026. Written by the Before You Hire a Pro editorial desk. Report an error.