What are the red flags of a bad contractor?
Short answer
The strongest warning signs are pressure to decide immediately, a demand for cash or full payment up front, no verifiable license or address, and a request that you pull the permit. Each appears on the FTC's or a state attorney general's own list. One sign is a reason to slow down and check; two or three together are a reason to end the conversation.
At the pitch
1. They found you. An unsolicited knock, with a story about being "in the area", leads the FTC's list. The Illinois Attorney General adds salespeople with no local connections offering work for substantially less than market price.
2. Leftover materials. The FTC lists the claim of materials left over from a previous job. Real contractors return surplus or keep it for their next scheduled customer.
3. Today-only pricing. Pressure for an immediate decision is on the FTC's list, and "a deal for today only" is on the Indiana Attorney General's. A discount for signing right away after a disaster is named in the FTC's weather emergency guidance too.
4. A free inspection from a stranger. Illinois warns about someone who offers to inspect your home for free without authentic identification establishing their business status.
5. A price far below everyone else's. California's license board says a substantially lower bid probably means a mistake or missing work. The Texas Attorney General calls it the "low-ball" bid.
In the paperwork
6. No license number, or one that does not check out. After a disaster the FTC warns specifically about contractors who say they do not need a license. In Arizona the Registrar reports many complaints from people who believed an advertisement's "licensed, bonded and insured".
7. No real address. A telephone number or post office box as the only contact details is an Illinois warning sign. An out-of-state plate or an unmarked vehicle is on the Illinois Attorney General's longer list.
8. No proof of insurance or references. A contractor who refuses to provide either when asked, per Illinois.
9. Blanks in the contract, or no time to read it. The Texas Attorney General: do not sign a contract with blanks, and be suspicious of anyone who rushes you, makes you sign on the spot or will not leave a copy for you to study.
10. You are asked to get the permit. On the FTC's list. See who pulls the permit.
At the payment
11. Cash only. The FTC: scammers ask you to pay for everything up front or only accept cash. Illinois: a contractor demanding cash payment or full payment before they complete a job.
12. A large payment before any work. In several states a big deposit is illegal as well as unwise. See how much deposit is normal.
13. A check to someone else. A request for a check payable to a third party is on the Illinois list. So is a contractor who wants to drive you to the bank to withdraw funds.
14. Their lender, their paperwork. Being steered to a lender the contractor knows is an FTC scam sign, and the start of the home improvement loan scam the FTC describes.
How to weigh them
Not every item is proof of fraud. A new sole trader may work from home and drive a plain van. A busy roofer may be bad at paperwork. The signs matter because of what they have in common: each one either removes your time to check, or removes your ability to get your money back.
| What the sign takes away | Signs |
|---|---|
| Time to compare and verify | 1, 2, 3, 9 |
| The ability to find them later | 6, 7, 8 |
| The ability to recover money | 11, 12, 13, 14 |
| Independent oversight of the work | 5, 10 |
A contractor who takes away two of those four things has made themselves very hard to hold to account, whatever their intentions.
What to do when you see one
- Slow down. No legitimate job is lost by waiting 48 hours.
- Verify. License or registration through your state lookup, insurance through the agent, address through a search.
- Get another bid. The fastest way to test a pitch is to hear a second contractor's view of the same work.
- Say no in one sentence. "I don't make decisions at the door" needs no follow-up.
- Report real fraud. To your state attorney general, and to the FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov.
Older homeowners are targeted on purpose. Illinois gives people over 65 up to 15 business days to cancel a contract signed at home. If a relative has signed something under pressure, check the cancellation date before anything else.
The contractor has several of these signs but did good work for a neighbor. What then?
Good work is real evidence. It does not answer for licensing, insurance or how payments are handled, so run the checks and structure the payments carefully.
Are online-only contractors a red flag?
Having no storefront is common and fine. Having no verifiable address, license or insurance is the problem, online or off.
Sources
- FTC: How to avoid a home improvement scam
- FTC: How to avoid scams after weather emergencies and natural disasters
- Illinois Attorney General: Avoid home repair fraud
- Illinois Attorney General: Home Repair and Construction, What You Should Know
- Indiana Attorney General: Storm chaser scams brochure
- Texas Attorney General: How to avoid home improvement scams
- California CSLB: How do I find the right licensed contractor?
- Arizona Registrar of Contractors: Before you hire a contractor
Sources last checked: November 2026. Written by the Before You Hire a Pro editorial desk. Report an error.