before you hire a pro

Paying

What is the safest way to pay a contractor?

Short answer

Pay by credit card or check, to the business name on the contract, and get a receipt every time. The FTC says to walk away from contractors who want cash up front and warns against wire transfers, gift cards, payment apps and cryptocurrency, because money sent that way is hard to get back. A credit card adds federal dispute rights.

Methods, from best to worst

MethodTraceCan you get it back?
Credit cardFull recordDispute rights under federal law, with conditions
Check to the businessBank record, endorsement shows who cashed itStop payment before it clears; otherwise through the contractor or a court
Bank transfer to a business accountRecord, but fast and finalRarely
Payment appRecord of a sortDifficult
CashNone unless you get a signed receiptNo
Wire transfer, gift cards, cryptocurrencyBuilt to be untraceable or irreversibleNo

The FTC's guidance after disasters names the bottom of that table directly: be wary of anyone who asks for payment by wire transfer, gift card, payment app, cryptocurrency or cash. Its standing advice is to pay by credit card or check.

Why the name on the payment matters

Michigan's licensing department gives the instruction in full: pay by check to the company name and always get a receipt.

A check made out to the business named on your contract and license record goes through that business's bank account. It leaves evidence of who received your money. A check made out to an individual, or to "cash", can be cashed by anyone and proves little. The Illinois Attorney General lists a contractor who asks for a check payable to a third party among its warning signs.

Before the first payment, compare three names: the contract, the license or registration record, and the payee line. They should match exactly.

What a credit card adds

Federal law gives credit card holders two distinct protections, and the FTC explains both.

Billing errors. If you are charged the wrong amount, or for something you did not accept or that was not delivered as agreed, you can dispute it as a billing error. Your letter must reach the card issuer within 60 days after the first bill containing the error was sent. The issuer must acknowledge the complaint in writing within 30 days, unless the problem is resolved first, and must resolve the dispute within 90 days.

Disputes about quality. Separately, you may be able to withhold payment for goods or services you are dissatisfied with. The conditions are set out in the federal regulation: the amount charged for the purchase exceeds $50, the transaction took place in your home state or within 100 miles of your billing address, and you made a good faith attempt to resolve the dispute with the seller first.

A home improvement job in your own house easily meets the location test. The practical limit is the balance. The regulation lets you withhold payment up to the amount of credit still outstanding for that purchase, so the right is strongest while the charge is recent. You also have to show you tried to sort it out with the contractor, which is another reason to complain in writing.

Many contractors add a surcharge for cards or refuse them for large amounts. A reasonable compromise is to put the deposit on a card, since the deposit is the payment made before any work exists, and pay later milestones by check against completed work.

Cash

There are honest contractors who offer a cash discount. Consider what you would be buying. You give up the bank's record, the dispute rights and, frequently, the receipt. If the discount exists because the income will not be reported, you are also dealing with someone comfortable with that.

The FTC's position is short: if they want cash up front, walk away. The Missouri Attorney General's is shorter: never pay in cash.

If you do pay any amount in cash, get a signed, dated receipt on the business's letterhead stating the amount, the job address and what the payment was for, before the money leaves your hand.

Receipts and records

For every payment keep:

  • the invoice it answered, with the contract milestone named
  • proof of payment (card statement, cleared check image from your bank)
  • a receipt from the contractor
  • the lien waiver that goes with it

The FTC's disaster guidance says to keep all invoices and receipts. If your payments were ever questioned, the cleared check image, showing the endorsement, is the single most persuasive document you can produce.

Joint checks

When a large part of a payment is really for a supplier or subcontractor, you can write the check to both parties. California's license board describes joint checks as the simplest way to prevent liens: you make the check payable to both the contractor and the supplier or subcontractor, and both must endorse it. The supplier gets paid, and you have proof.

Paying when an insurer is involved

After an insured loss the check may arrive made out to you, or to you and your mortgage company. The FTC is firm that you should not sign your insurance check over to a contractor. Deposit it, and pay the contractor yourself on the schedule in your contract. See storm chasers after a disaster.

Warning

Never give a contractor your online banking login, a signed blank check, or permission to "pull the payment" from your account. Each payment should be an act you perform after looking at the work.

The contractor only takes payment through an app. Is that a problem?

It is a weaker record than a check and comes without card dispute rights. For small jobs, with a written receipt, the risk is modest. For anything substantial, ask to pay by check to the business name.

Can I dispute a card charge if the contractor never showed up?

Services not delivered as agreed are the kind of thing the billing error process covers. Write to the card issuer within 60 days of the statement, and keep a copy.

Sources

Sources last checked: November 2026. Written by the Before You Hire a Pro editorial desk. Report an error.