before you hire a pro

Finding

General contractor or specialty contractor: which do you need?

Short answer

Hire a specialty contractor when the job is one trade, such as a water heater, a roof or a panel upgrade. Hire a general contractor when several trades have to be scheduled around each other. Then check that the license you find covers that kind of work, because states issue licenses by category and a license for one category is not a license for another.

The working difference

A general contractor sells coordination. They take responsibility for the whole job, hire and schedule the trades, order materials and deal with the inspector. California's license board describes it this way: a general building contractor may perform all of the work on a building, or subcontract parts of the job to contractors with specialty licenses.

A specialty contractor sells one trade done by their own people: roofing, plumbing, electrical, tile, painting.

If your project is a single trade, a general contractor adds a markup and a layer of communication you do not need. If it is a kitchen, with demolition, framing, plumbing, electrical, drywall, cabinets and flooring arriving in a strict order, acting as your own general contractor means the scheduling, the gaps between trades and the arguments about whose fault the delay is all become yours.

One trade or several: a quick sort

JobUsually hire
Replace a water heaterPlumbing contractor
ReroofRoofing contractor
Replace the electrical panelElectrical contractor
New furnace or air conditionerHVAC contractor
Bathroom gut and rebuildGeneral contractor, or a remodeler licensed for it
Kitchen remodelGeneral contractor
AdditionGeneral contractor
Paint the exteriorPainting contractor

The middle of the table is where people get into trouble. A "bathroom guy" who does his own plumbing and electrical is common. Whether that is legal depends on what his license covers in your state.

Licenses come in categories

A license is permission to do a named kind of work. Four states show how different the categories can be.

California. The Contractors State License Board issues licenses in 45 classifications, ranging from general contractors to swimming pool contractors, landscapers, painters, electricians and plumbers. The lookup shows which classifications a license holds.

Florida. The Construction Industry Licensing Board licenses general, building and residential contractors along with trades including roofing, air conditioning, mechanical, plumbing and pool work. Each is further split into certified (statewide) and registered (specific local jurisdictions). See Florida.

Michigan. A Residential Builder license covers building a complete house and remodeling. A Maintenance and Alteration Contractor license covers only the trades printed on it, from a list that includes carpentry, concrete, masonry, roofing, siding, insulation, gutters and tile and marble. See Michigan.

Virginia. The Board for Contractors splits a license into a class, which limits project value, and a classification or specialty, which limits the type of work. Both must fit your job. See Virginia.

The lesson is the same in each. "Licensed" is an incomplete sentence. Licensed for what?

Trades that are licensed even where general contractors are not

Several large states have no statewide general contractor license at all and still license particular trades. Texas licenses electricians and air conditioning contractors through its Department of Licensing and Regulation, and plumbers through a separate board. Ohio's state board licenses electrical, HVAC, plumbing, hydronics and refrigeration contractors for commercial work and leaves residential rules to local government. Illinois licenses roofing contractors at state level.

So on a remodel in one of those states, your general contractor may hold no state license while the electrician working under them must. Ask the general contractor for the license numbers of the licensed trades they plan to use, and look those up. The CSLB gives the same instruction for lien reasons: make sure your contractor hires only licensed subcontractors, and check their licenses.

Questions that settle it

  1. How many trades touch this job? Count them honestly, including the ones hiding behind a wall.
  2. Does it need a permit, and who will be named on it? The contractor who pulls the permit is the one answerable to the inspector.
  3. What does the license record say they may do? Read the classification, not the business name. A company called Premier Home Solutions can be licensed for anything or nothing.
  4. Who are the subcontractors? The CSLB advises getting a list of all subcontractors, laborers and material suppliers your direct contractor will use.

Managing the trades yourself

Hiring each trade directly saves the general contractor's markup and makes you the scheduler, the quality control and the person the inspector calls. In some states it also changes your legal position. California's board warns that as an owner-builder you, not the people you hire, assume responsibility for the overall job, which may include state and federal taxes, workers' compensation and other legal liabilities. It also warns about "consultants" who talk owners into this arrangement to save money.

For two unrelated trades, such as a roofer in spring and an electrician in autumn, hiring direct is simple. For a job where the trades depend on each other's timing, the general contractor's fee usually buys something real.

Can a general contractor do the electrical work themselves?

Only if their license, or a separate one they hold, covers electrical work in your state. In states that license electricians separately, the electrical portion needs that license regardless of who the general contractor is.

What is a remodeler?

A trade description, not a license category in most states. Look up what license the business actually holds and what that license allows.

Sources

Sources last checked: November 2026. Written by the Before You Hire a Pro editorial desk. Report an error.