before you hire a pro

Printable checklist

Vetting a roofer after a storm: checklist

Storm damage puts you under time pressure, which is when shortcuts get taken. Work down this list in order. The first section happens before you speak to any roofer.

Prints on plain paper with empty boxes to tick.

Before you talk to a roofer

  • I photographed the damage from the ground and inside the attic, with dates.
  • I called my insurance company and opened a claim myself.
  • I asked my insurer what my policy covers and what my deductible is.
  • Temporary protection is in place (tarp, boards), and I kept the receipts.
  • I have the adjuster's estimate, or an appointment for one, to use as a benchmark.

At the door

  • I did not let an uninvited caller onto the roof.
  • I did not sign anything on the day, including "inspection" or "authorization" forms.
  • I took a business card and said I would call.

Checking each roofer

  • Business name and a physical address I can find on a map.
  • State license or registration checked on the regulator's website, if my state has one for roofing. (Illinois licenses roofers; Georgia does not require a state license for them; Texas has no state roofing program.)
  • For Florida: the license is certified, or registered for my own county.
  • Certificate of insurance received from the agent, showing workers' compensation and general liability.
  • Two references from local jobs done before this storm, and I called them.
  • I have written estimates from more than one roofer.

The estimate and contract

  • Tear-off, underlayment, flashing, ventilation and the roofing product are specified by name.
  • A unit price is stated for replacing rotted decking.
  • The roofer obtains any permit.
  • Start date and expected duration are stated.
  • Workmanship warranty is in writing.
  • No blank spaces. No clause promising the job to this roofer just for meeting the adjuster.
  • Cancellation notice is included if I am signing at home.
  • Nobody has offered to waive or rebate my deductible.

Paying

  • I am not signing my insurance check over to the roofer.
  • Deposit is modest and within any state limit.
  • In Texas, an out-of-area disaster contractor has not asked for payment before starting work.
  • I am paying by check or card to the business name, never cash, wire, gift card or payment app.
  • Final payment waits for completion, cleanup, any inspection and lien waivers from the roofer and the shingle supplier.

Afterward

  • I have the warranty, the product names and photos of the finished roof.
  • I reported anyone who pressured or misled me to my state attorney general and at ReportFraud.ftc.gov.

Why this order

The Texas Attorney General recommends having your adjuster estimate the damage first, so you negotiate from a professional benchmark. The FTC warns after weather emergencies about contractors who say they need no license, offer a discount for signing right away, or ask you to sign over your insurance check, and reminds people that FEMA does not charge application fees. The Indiana Attorney General's advice is to choose the local, well-established contractor.

The roofer says the offer ends when the crew leaves town on Friday. What then?

Let it end. A roof installed by a crew that will be several states away when it leaks is the outcome this list exists to prevent.

Sources

Sources last checked: November 2026. Report an error.