When a job goes wrong: paper trail checklist
When a job turns bad, the person with the better file usually gets the better outcome. This list is about building that file, in order, starting today.
Today
- Photograph and video the problem and the whole site, with the date showing or noted.
- Write down what happened, in order, with dates. One page.
- Gather the contract, change orders, every invoice and every proof of payment.
- Add up what I have paid and what work has been completed.
- Stop further payments until the position is clear.
- Make anything dangerous or open to weather safe, and keep the receipts.
- From now on, communicate in writing. Follow any phone call with an email confirming what was said.
This week
- Send the contractor a letter by certified mail, return receipt requested: the problem, what I want, a deadline.
- Keep a copy of the letter, the enclosures and the mailing receipt.
- Re-check the contractor's license or registration record and print it.
- Read my contract for clauses on notice, default, dispute resolution and arbitration.
- Ask a second licensed contractor for a written assessment of what is wrong and the cost to fix or finish.
- Call the building department and ask the inspector to look at the work, if it was permitted.
- Check whether any subcontractor or supplier is unpaid.
If the deadline passes
- File a complaint with the board that licensed or registered the contractor.
- File with my state attorney general's consumer protection division.
- If fraud or theft: report at ReportFraud.ftc.gov and to the police.
- If I paid by credit card: write to the card issuer. A billing error dispute must arrive within 60 days of the statement.
- Ask the board about its recovery or guaranty fund and the separate claim form, if my state has one.
- Note every deadline in a calendar.
Deadlines to look up for my state
- How long I have to complain to the board. (California's board acts on violations for up to four years from the act.)
- How long I have to claim from a fund. (Maryland: three years from discovering the loss.)
- The small claims limit for my court.
- Any notice period in my contract.
If a lien notice arrives
- Get a copy of what was recorded.
- Send it to the contractor in writing and demand they resolve it.
- Check the claimant against my lien waivers and payment records.
- Speak to an attorney if the amount is significant.
Things not to do
- I have not let anyone remove or cover the defective work before it was documented.
- I have not paid disputed amounts to make the argument stop.
- I have not signed anything offered "to settle this" without reading it twice.
- I have not aired the dispute online.
What the agencies expect
The FTC's sequence for a problem with a contractor is to try to resolve it with the contractor, follow up calls with a certified letter, keep notes and copies, and then turn to the state attorney general or local consumer protection office. California's license board asks whether you formally notified the contractor and wants a copy of that letter with the complaint. Maryland's commission puts the burden of proof on the homeowner at a Guaranty Fund hearing. Each of those is a reason to keep records as if a stranger will read them, because one will.
I do not want a fight. Is all this necessary?
Most disputes end with the certified letter. Preparing the rest is what makes that letter credible, and it costs an afternoon.
Sources
- FTC: How to avoid a home improvement scam
- FTC: Using credit cards and disputing charges
- California CSLB: Filing a construction complaint
- Maryland Home Improvement Commission: File a complaint
Sources last checked: November 2026. Report an error.